Freedom vs Responsibility

Imam Shamsi Ali*

When we discuss freedom, we're touching on a fundamental aspect of our faith that holds immense significance. Freedom transcends mere annual celebrations; it is the very essence of faith and a very basic human right. The declaration of "Laa ilaaha illallah" (There is no god but Allah) embodies a profound commitment to embracing true freedom. By proclaiming this declaration, an individual liberates himself from all forms of servitude and enslavement, submitting solely to the sovereignty of Allah, the King of the heavens and earth.

Any form of servitude or submission to other than Allah contradicts the principle of Tawhid (the oneness of God). True freedom originates from the liberation of the heart and soul from all forms of bondage, except to Allah. This inner freedom then manifests in various aspects of social life, including politics, economics, and socio-cultural dimensions.

In Islam, freedom and religion are inextricably linked, much like fish and water. Without freedom, Islam becomes lifeless, much like a fish out of water. Despite the presence of Islamic symbols in many Muslim countries, the spirit of the religion has withered away due to the absence of true freedom.

Islam advocates for responsible freedom – freedom that is guided by a sense of accountability and responsibility. Freedom without responsibility is antithetical to a civilized society that values boundaries and moral principles. This distinction is what sets Muslims apart in their understanding of freedom.

As we commemorate the Independence Day, let us strive to build a society that embodies responsible freedom – freedom that is anchored in the divine and guided by truth. Without this balance, freedom can lead to irresponsible behavior, and individuals may find themselves enslaved by their own desires, despite feeling free.

To all Americans, happy  Independence Day!

Jamaica Hills, July 4, 2025 

*A Proud New Yorker